Issues
Try out Yarn instead of npm
Description
Details
Details
Assignee

Reporter

Labels
Tested Version/s
Story Points
Components
Sprint
Fix versions
Priority

More fields
Time tracking
More fields
Time trackingActivity

Former user20 December 2016 at 21:59Edited
Initial research:
dev machine uses nvm to manage version on npm/node, nvm does not support yarn, https://github.com/creationix/nvm/issues/1280. I've tried to use nvm to manage node version, and yarn is installed globally (-g) and it works. As long as the node version is consistence, it should be fine.
we use frontend-maven-plugin to download npm/node, need to replace with yarn, https://github.com/eirslett/frontend-maven-plugin#installing-node-and-yarn
all other command we use at the moment is supported by yarn
jenkins config of yarn?
Run (zanata-frontend module):
(yarn) mvn clean install 124.13s user 11.78s system 141% cpu 1:35.91 total
(npm) mvn clean install 285.47s user 20.03s system 122% cpu 4:08.57 total
Jenkins (zanata-frontend):
(npm)Zanata frontend 8 min 6 sec
(yarn)Zanata frontend 6 min 19 sec

Sean Flanigan15 December 2016 at 08:23
This looks interesting: https://medium.com/@boennemann/avoid-yarn-for-packages-and-fully-enjoy-its-benefits-for-application-development-8bdd4deb33cf#.6f3gni2jq I had no idea npm was downloading all those tarballs to check shrinkwrap files, but it helps to explain the terrible performance.
The fact that yarn apparently ignores dependencies' shrinkwrap/yarn.lock files is a bit of a concern. But it seems to me that whenever you use yarn upgrade
(or npm install --no-shrinkwrap; npm shrinkwrap --dev
) you will get the latest version (within a semver range) of everything anyway, so it may not be much worse in practice.
Yarn appears to address npm's most important shortcomings: reproducibility, security and performance. It's still pretty new, but given our problems with npm, I think we should give it a try.
Official announcement: https://code.facebook.com/posts/1840075619545360
A comparison: https://www.sitepoint.com/yarn-vs-npm/
Notes:
Timebox this to 3 days